Dachshund Australia

Family bred, raised and loved mini dachshunds

  • Home
  • Who we are
  • Breed Health
  • Breeder Insights
  • Coat type & temperament
  • Celebrating colours, coats and patterns
  • Puppies
    • Adults for adoption
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Contact Us

Breeders just think they are God

June 9, 2014 by Fiona Douglas Leave a Comment

Last night I was watching 60 Minutes as a father and mother related the tale of their young son’s battle with cancer[1]. A big part of the story was the double whammy that struck when, in the reporter’s words, “Life’s game of chance delivered another cruel hand.”

Namely, the boy’s father was diagnosed with cancer just a few months after his son. The father explained to us, “I mean, how do the two boys in the family get cancer at the same time? It’s just ridiculous. I mean, [my cancer] is not related to [my son’s]; this is not some rogue cancer gene.”

This resonated with me as a dog breeder, for it occurred to me that all too often breeders are guilty of setting themselves the impossible expectation that every creature they breed will enjoy a blessed and trouble free life. Yet as human beings, we don’t even hold this unrealistic expectation for our own species.

Good dog breeders are their own worst enemy in this regard, I have found. If we hear of any ailment among our flock – whatever the age – we agonize over the if-buts-and-maybes in a way nobody would if a human friend or family member was dealt the same ‘cruel hand’.

In truth such agonizing is a measure of the breeder’s care-factor. We feel the pain of the dog owner and the dog and we want beyond anything for that pain not to have happened and never to happen again.

Just mention the word ’genetic’- even just in passing and even as an unproven possible link to a dog’s health problem – and the breeder thrusts themselves into the hot seat as if they miraculously somehow have control over all-things-bad in life.

If only.

And so it was the 60 Minutes segment gave me insight that might help other breeders who occasionally find themselves grappling in the wee hours of the dead of night with the seemingly capricious nature of life’s game … for that’s the game we are in.

I am speaking here to breeders who are already doing everything within their power to breed healthy dogs. Just as most people set out to produce the healthiest children possible, so too good breeders set out to produce robust puppies.

In the case of animal breeding, this means working with the best knowledge and science of the day. This involves a sound knowledge of the possible disorders of dogs generally and your own breed specifically. There are industry recognized authoritative guides in this regard, such as the LIDA list of genetic conditions in the various breeds assembled as a breeding tool for Australian dog breeders. It lists the very numerous genetic conditions that can exist for the various purebreeds.

Good breeders are armed with such knowledge and have scrupulous screening processes in place for breeding adults, plus a means of recording any reported ailments. Specialist pet breeders go one step further and embrace a wide gene pool, never breeding relative to relative no matter how distant. The wide gene pool is a good safety measure against the unknown, because it reduces the chances of any harmful recessive genes lurking within a family to surface in the form of disease.

Over and above this, there is not a lot more that can be done. It would be nice if there were screening tests for every conceivable disorder, but there are not. And even the few tests that do exist have big question marks over them (the PRA genetic test is just one example here).

Yet despite doing all humanly possible, still the desire to be all-controlling pervades into the wee hours for many of us. And so it is here I will continue the analogy of our more logical and reasoned acceptance of human ailments in the hope that breeders can take heed and drop the breeder God complex.

I’ve chosen three diseases as examples, because these are commonly known and occur in both humans and dogs. Of course the list could be very much longer – and people can do their own Googling in this regard.

Brain seizures

Brain seizures have a genetic link. A whopping 10% of Australians suffer from brain seizures. A cause can only be found in half of all sufferers, and these are numerous in origin with a genetic link just one of them. And in regard to that genetic link, there are thought to be 500 different genes at play in bringing about the condition.

It is therefore the case that brain seizures can occur in an individual without any trace of that condition in any of their relatives, past or present.

Accordingly, from a dog breeding perspective, the opportunity to have ‘better bred’ an afflicted animal is nigh impossible, exception being in the rare case that a breeding animal or their progeny presented with the condition.

Breast cancer

Breast cancer has a genetic link. Specifically, it has a genetic link in 5% of cases.  In 95% of cases, there is no genetic link. About 10% of women will get breast cancer.

Is it rational, therefore, for a dog breeder to beat themselves up if breast cancer should develop in an individual dog when there has been no familial link at all? No clue, no evidence, no signs?

Diabetes

Diabetes has a genetic link. But the causes are unknown and in many cases, diabetes strikes without any family history at all.

In dog breeding terms, the hereditary cause of diabetes can be tackled if it appears in breeding dogs or their progeny. But for the plethora of other causes, the best breeder simply has to accept that they have no control here.

So, to all good breeders out there Lady Fi says: keep agonizing and searching because that reminds us just how much we care and keeps us all on our toes to continue doing our very best. But when the best is done, sleep soundly in the knowledge and acceptance that you are not God and you never will be.

 


[1] http://sixtyminutes.ninemsn.com.au/stories/8855816/rorys-story-the-11-year-old-boy-fighting-a-rare-football-sized-tumour-in-his-abdomen

Filed Under: Breed Health Tagged With: breeders, breeding, dachshund, dachshund Australia, deckel, doxie, genetics, health, puppies, puppy, sausage dog, weiner dog

About Fiona Douglas

Fiona Douglas B.Agr. Sc. (Hons) M. S. W.
Fiona is an Agricultural Scientist and breeder of miniature dachshunds. She also holds a masters degree in Social Work.
Fiona is passionate about the welfare of dogs and raising the quality of life for all breeding dogs. For 20 years she has been a magazine and newspaper editor, but now it's dogs full time!

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Cart

Instagram Feed

Load More...
Follow on Instagram

Articles by Lady Fi

Do dogs bite? aka Do cars crash?

Do dogs bite? aka Do cars crash?

Four weeks ago the unthinkable happened. Our Chihuahua of nine years standing, Wilbur, was summarily dispatched by his best mate of a lifetime, our six year old Cardigan Corgi, Percy. Wilbur was dead, no doubt. But thanks to instantaneous intervention (I was one metre away and witnessed the deed) he came back to us. And […]

New Puppy on a Budget

New Puppy on a Budget

Buying a puppy is expensive, but buying all those puppy-extras doesn’t have to be. True, a whole new and unexplored consumer market has just opened to you but it doesn’t need to bankrupt you. And as a dedicated bargain hunter from way-back, I thought I would share my tips with fellow puppy-parents. I find that […]

Inviting disaster – off lead parks & doggy daycare

By Fiona Douglas Dogs randomly frolicking around off-leash is a heartwarming scene to most people. But not to me, nor other breeders I have spoken to. To us, it’s a disaster waiting to happen and it’s stressful to watch. Our knowledge of dogs tells us that the calmest and happiest environment can – in a snap – switch to uncontrolled violence […]

Life or death – whose choice is it?

Life or death – whose choice is it?

Still I get a cold chill down my spine when I recall a term that was explained to me very many years ago; before I was even a dog breeder. The term, or more accurately the phrase, was ‘they bucket them’.  An experienced show breeder explained to me that it was common practise for puppies […]

Why become a dog breeder?

Why become a dog breeder?

Fiona Douglas describes why she and her husband are companion animal breeders. Breeding companion animals is – for an animal lover – the most wonderful thing imaginable. For me it without doubt stands as one of the most authentic and rewarding things I have ever experienced. Our path to breeding really started back in 1980 […]

Latest comments

  • Andrea Shuck on Double dapple danger
  • Fiona Douglas on Double dapple danger
  • Andrea Shuck on Double dapple danger
  • Fiona Douglas on Double dapple danger
  • Fiona Douglas on Angular limb deformity
  • Barb on Double dapple danger
  • Jasmin on Angular limb deformity

© Copyright 2007-2018 Dachshund Australia · ABN 63 603 388 558 · Registered Victorian breeder, DAB 35 Wellington Shire Council · Wembaster